Matthew Paris tells us the story of William de Marisco, and helpfully also provides illustrations — here, de Marisco is being dragged from Westminster to the Tower of London, July 24, 1242. This is from Paris’s Chronica Majora, which he finished in 1259, on account of no longer being alive.
The de Mariscos were a family that continually got into trouble, on account of continually misbehaving. When William de Marisco was executed at the Tower of London in 1242, it was ostensibly for attempting to have the king murdered, but since he’d also been pirating from the Isle of Lundy, and murdering messengers, he was going to end up being executed at some point anyway. Besides explaining the de Mariscos, we have two rabbit holes! Anne is fascinated by the Isle of Lundy, and Michelle is fascinated by Matthew Paris, and really, there’s a lot going on in this episode.
Here we see an illustration of Snorri, by Christian Krogh, from an 1899 edition of Heimskringla. Has anybody made an illustration of Snorri getting assassinated in his basement? They have not. Your host finds this annoying. But versions of Snorri himself — that we have.
Snorri Sturluson, the great Icelandic poet and historian and lawspeaker of the Althing, got involved in Norwegian/Icelandic politics, and it ended very badly. For him, for one thing, as the king of Norway arranged for 70 men to stab Snorri in his basement, and for Iceland as well, which devolved into chieftain battles and eventually unified with Norway, and the Norwegian king became the boss of everything. The Althing still exists, though, and Iceland is independent now, and Snorri is one of the most influential poets of the early middle ages. We explain all this. Anne still wonders why you need 70 people to stab somebody in his basement, and Michelle is shocked, shocked, I tell you, that there isn’t any historical fiction about all this, though she is slightly mollified by the fact that there is now a Snorri ap, for Android and IOS. Well, then.
Here we have a lovely postcard, depicting the use of the medieval shame flute. Which didn’t exist. But it’s all over the internet! And there are two in museums! Alas, no evidence. But the postcards are nice! Also, Michelle fell down several rabbit holes.
If you go and peruse the internet, you will discover many discussions of the medieval shame flute, an instrument created specifically to be fastened to a bad musician, in order to shame him. There are pictures. There is a lot of certainty about this. Alas, it wasn’t there. Michelle went to find them, and, though there are a couple of torture museums which have examples, those are not medieval examples. In fact, do we think that there were ever any shame flutes, even after the middle ages? We do not. Because we think, really, when bad musicians come to your town, you can just make them leave. And then not hire them any more. Michelle found some pretty nifty postcards, though, with lots of shaming devices, and you can buy them. And send them to your friends.
Here we have a depiction of Diarmait, as found in Giraldus Cambrensis’s Expugnatio, dating from not long after the Norman Invasion. Unusual, really, for us, since most of our illustrations come from long after our subjects, and often aren’t of them at all. But here he is.
At the end of the 12th century, the kings of Ireland had been fighting amongst themselves, and the high king got involved, and what with one thing and another Diarmait Mac Murchada, who had been the king of Leinster, and then had been ousted, and then had gotten in again, got ousted again, and then had the very bad idea of getting help from the Anglo-Normans. And they did help, didn’t they, and then they took Ireland over. This could have been foreseen by anybody who had been paying attention to how the Normans operated. Diarmait, at any rate, got to be king again, though not for long, and then he got to live in infamy as a great traitor. For the Irish. The English liked him better. Michelle gets even more exercised than usual, because 1) colonialism, very bad, and 2) some scholars she found, also very bad.
This isn’t Richard Walweyn, who was a servant in London; this is Lord Darnley and his little brother. Today, Lord Darnley is wearing padded hose. Which he gets to, on account of his high status. Later, he will marry Mary Queen of Scots. That won’t go well, but today he looks great. (Hans Eworth, 1563. Now at Holyroodhouse, Edinburgh.)
One day in London in 1565, Richard Walweyn was arrested for wearing the wrong pants, and put in jail until he could prove he owned some proper ones. And why were these the wrong pants? Cause they were puffed out, and he was a servant. Makes no sense, right? Nah. But in times of unease, people like to try to get everybody to wear the right clothes, eat the right things, buy the right stuff. Whatever those things are that year. We discuss sumptuary laws over time, we discuss the hell which would be More’s Utopia, if you found yourself living in it, and Michelle, bless her heart, found Italian Traveling Earrings.
Stories of cannibalism, infanticide, and child abandonment in the Great Famine were rife then, and continue now. The crime rate rose, certainly, but the more lurid stories haven’t much evidence behind them. However. The child abandonment story came down to us as Hansel and Gretel. (Illustration by Kay Neilsen, 1925.)
In 1315, the crops throughout Europe failed. And then they failed the year after that. And then the year after that. It was raining. And it rained and rained and rained. After that , it rained some more. One of the greatest natural disasters of the middle ages was the Great Famine, in which so many people of Europe died that the population didn’t reach the level it had been before the rain started until the 19th century. Naturally, the crime rate rose. That’s a fact. However, the cannibalism and infanticide stories, though they were very well known, don’t have any evidence. Despite Hansel and Gretel. So we figured there was a rise in theft, and a rise in piracy, but not widespread cannibalism. Michelle found a very good book. And a very bad one.
Davy Gam was born in Penywaun, near Brecon, where later he would kill a kinsman in the High Street. His father, Llewelyn ap Hywel, had bought an estate there. Here’s Penywaun! It looks different now.
Before Davy Gam got famous amongst the English for helping out at Agincourt and getting knighted, and being in general an acceptable Welshman on account of helping out the English and fighting Welshmen, he had killed a kinsman in Brecon, had fought under John of Gaunt, and had fought against Owain Glyndŵr, the leader of the last great Welsh rebellion and the last Welsh Prince of Wales. As you can imagine, a Welshman famous amongst the English for bravely serving them and fighting at Agincourt is not necessarily a Welsh hero. But! He gives Anne an excuse for talking about Owain Glyndŵr, and Michelle an excuse for explaining why John Powys is not as good an author as Tolkien. Also, we discuss how it is that families in an occupied country might well find themselves on different sides of a conflict.
Not at Christmas, not in Saxony, not in the 10th century, BUT here are people dancing a carole. One of them is Lancelot. (Evrard d’Espinques from ‘Lancelot du Lac’ c. 1470. Bibliothèque nationale de France, fr.115 f475.)
Once upon a time, a group of parishioners in a village in Saxony danced in the churchyard during Christmas Mass, and so the priest cursed them and then they danced without ceasing for a year. This story was told, with variations, throughout Europe, from the 10th century (at least) through the 16th century. And! It really happened! Ok, not the dancing without ceasing for a year part, but the dancing without being able to stop? That really happened. From the 14th through the 17th century, groups of people throughout Europe would start dancing maniacally, and be unable to stop. Sometimes they did this till they died. And we still don’t know why this occurred, though it is recognized as a Thing That Really Happened. We discuss dancing mania, the cursed carolers legends, and try to make sense of it all. Happy Holidays!
Clifford’s Tower wasn’t there when the Jews of York were massacred, but it stands there now, and the mound has been planted with daffodils in remembrance and honor of the dead. The flowers have six petals, reminiscent of the Star of David, and bloom in March, near the anniversary of the atrocity.
A wave of anti-Semitism and atrocities against the Jews swept England starting in 1189, when Richard Lionheart was crowned, and mobs in London attacked the Jews in that city. The worst of the atrocities happened in York, when the local mobs burnt and pillaged Jewish homes; when the Jews retreated to the castle keep (they were, theoretically and legally, under the protection of the king), the York mob besieged the wooden keep with stones, and murdered some of the Jews, having lured them out of the keep with the promise of safety if they converted. The Jews of York committed suicide, and burnt down the keep. Lately, work has been done to create an honorable, respectful, and informative permanent exhibit, making sure that this piece of York history is known and remembered. Michelle, having found no operas and novels featuring this atrocity, explains the history of York castle. And also Henry III’s toilet.
This is one of the illustrations made by George Cruikshank for the 1840 edition of William Harrison Ainsworth’s Guy Fawkes, or The Gunpowder Treason, an historical novel that made Edgar Allan Poe very upset indeed. Here, Guy is in Ordsall Cave, philosophically pondering how best to commit domestic terrorism. (Did Guy and his cohorts plan the Gunpowder Plot in Ordsall? No. Ainsworth made that up.
Special Episode! It’s the third birthday of True Crime Medieval, but, more importantly really, it’s the 417th anniversary of the Gunpowder Plot not actually coming off; if it had, not only King James and all of Parliament would have been destroyed, but also several blocks around, including Westminster Abbey. We discuss the Plot, why it didn’t work, what’s been going on with November 5th celebrations since then, and, because Michelle finds this stuff, Edgar Allan Poe and his hatred for William Harrison Ainsworth’s historical novel about the whole affair.